We don’t know enough about student homelessness in Canada and in this guest blog Dr. Eric Weissman explores the research he’s done on the issue and how much more work needs to happen to properly address the problem. He will be presenting at our National Conference on Ending Homelessness next week.
By Dr. Eric Weissman, Ph.D.
Associate Professor, University of New Brunswick Department of Social Science, Saint John
“A few days ago, one of my students came up to me–this is after I had submitted all the final grades for her class. I told her that if she had showed up more, been more on top of her work, well then, maybe then I could have reconsidered her failing grade. Then she, well, she kind of broke my heart and made me angry at the same time: she said, ‘Well, you wouldn’t feel that way if you knew I have been homeless this whole term.’ And she walked away. I literally didn’t know what to say or do. You tell me; what do we do?” (Anon. instructor at RDC College in Central Alberta December 18, 2017)
Those of us who work in education and in poverty research know from anecdotal information gathered in collaborations with homeless adults and older youth that student homelessness is a taboo subject and likely more wide-spread than we know. It does not take a great leap of faith to imagine that student homelessness occurs at the great expense of individuals’ dreams and hopes, lost productivity in our economies and the cultural wealth of our communities.
In Canada to date, we have no idea how big a problem it is, how it is distributed regionally and across other dimensions such as, age, gender and ethnicity; we do not know what it costs us as a nation in terms of the health and social wellbeing of our citizens or the economic and cultural impacts on our communities.
In 2014, there were 5,032,000 students in all levels of education in Canada; just over 2 million of these were in Post-Secondary Institutions (Stats. Can. 2016). With the Federal Government’s position on prevention, it is sensible to address student homelessness as a unique lived experience requiring specific supports and interventions.
Research done by Housing and Urban Development, the US Department of Education and various US State Department’s of Education, cited in Ilyana Keyohane (COH, 2016) and Weissman (2017) suggests that as many as 1.4 million US students fall under the category of homelessness. These experiences range from being literally unsheltered to couch surfing. Newspapers tend to carry these stories because of the dramatic nature – homeless students? Students failing at courses, unable to find jobs, sleeping in gymnasiums, libraries, stairwells of empty academic buildings, and riding subways all night; each seems to be an almost unbelievable story, except they are frighteningly common.
In Canada, there are 2 million Post Secondary students. We do not know how many of them are homeless or at-risk. However, we have anecdotal evidence from staff and students, and from homeless youth we work with, that student homelessness is a hidden but large and costly problem. How big is it? Where does it happen? What are the costs?
The RDC Baseline Test
I undertook a small exploratory survey of students at Red Deer College in 2017 while I was an instructor. Students enrolled in courses in the humanities and social sciences were asked to freely and anonymously respond to an online survey – approximately 190 responses were gathered from a pool of approximately 1,200 students.
Some basic data about the sample are:
- 84% Female, 14% male and 2.5% Gender Queer/Gender Non-conforming
- 83% Canadian, 9% FNMI, 8% Ethnic Canadian
- 55% between 18 and 22 years of age
- 18.5% very well-off families, 40% well-off, 25% – well off and optimistic (please see survey for categories)
- 60% earned less than 15,000 CDN/yr., 22% earned 15-24,000 CDN/yr.
- 43% of respondents had had mental health diagnoses, 23.7% were ongoing (We found this a curious, if not troubling result: it is twice the expected rate. It could mean that students with this experience were more likely to fill out the survey. Again, this is a type of result we would want to refine in our proposed research).
Consider these very early results:
- 5% of current students said they had previously experienced homelessness (as defined by the COH typology)
- 70% of this was “hidden homelessness”
- 7% had lived completely unsheltered
- Here is the troubling figure. Of that 24%, almost half were students at the time they experienced homeless
- Only 2.6% reported current homelessness – responses suggested an additional group homeless by our definition, but that they found it hard to see it that way.
- 62% said they never hear stories about other students being homeless, but 17% suggested they do hear stories about it.
- Of those who reported hearing stories, 50% suggested they heard it about 2 or more students. Again, sensitivity to the issue may lead to greater awareness and disclosure.
- 31% of students said they worried about their housing and this stress was a major concern impacting the performance of 48% of these people. (Respondents offered elaborate explanations of what this stress looks like)
- Alarmingly, almost 40% of students suggested they would do anything to find shelter. And this has obvious implications for understanding the criminalization and exploitation of youth.
There are an additional 32 questions on the survey that will be analyzed, and once again, the reader is reminded that this survey is preliminary. We are only beginning to understand its implications. However, given that there are approximately 2,000,000 students in post-secondary schools in Canada, if the 2.6% of current homelessness turns out be a universal and valid rate, then 52,000 Canadian students are currently experiencing some kind of homelessness. If the deleterious impact of homelessness suggested in these responses is also universal, then we have a certain moral obligation in addition to numerous practical considerations, to address this issue rapidly.
These issues and more in-depth discussion of future research plans will be discussed in my session at next week’s National Conference on Ending Homelessness. In the meantime, any researchers or students interested in participating or contributing ideas can reach me at firstname.lastname@example.org.
“Don’t wait until the end of the day to figure out where you’re sleeping that night. It makes it far more stressful. Try to focus on class the best you can and know that if you stick with it, it will pass. Reach out and let people know the situation that you’re in, even if you’re embarrassed about it because it may not even be your fault. Make sure you’re fed and just keep your head up.” RDC student.
Catch Dr. Eric Weissman at the National Conference on Ending Homelessness on Nov. 6 for his session, Research Roundup. This interactive Speed Geeking session will give participants the chance to learn from experts on topics ranging from youth homelessness and the education system to a case study on social network analysis; from outcomes measurement in evaluating services to the role empowerment (identity capital) has on young people transitioning out of homelessness. Participants will spend time at each presentation station and with plenty of time to ask questions at each station.
Award-winning Inuk singer, songwriter and activist Susan Aglukark will be one of our keynote speakers at the upcoming National Conference on Ending Homelessness from Nov. 5-7–our biggest one to date! We’ll be live streaming our keynote presentations on Facebook throughout the three days.